Tip Menu for OnlyFans – How to Set Up and Boost Your Earnings

We have run hundreds of pricing experiments across our portfolio of 20+ managed creators. The same video at $19 or $39, $3 effective subs versus $10, tip menus with 8 tiers versus 3. The results are often counter-intuitive: higher prices sell better, subscriptions barely move total revenue, and the $15–25 mass PPV is the underpriced gold mine in almost every niche. This guide drops the actual benchmarks we use when building tip menus and pricing structures for our accounts.

What Is an OnlyFans Tip Menu?

An OnlyFans tip menu is a clear, organised list of the extra services, content and interactions you offer, with a price next to each one. Think of it as a restaurant menu: fans can browse, pick what they want, and see exactly what it costs before they tip.

For creators, a tip menu is more than a convenience — it is a sales tool. It sets clear expectations, cuts the back-and-forth in the DMs, and makes your page read as a business rather than a hobby. Most importantly, it opens the door to higher earnings, because fans who can see the options buy things they would never have thought to ask for.

Done properly, the menu adds transparency and structure. Fans feel more comfortable buying, and you stop improvising a price every time somebody asks.

Why Does Every Creator Need a Tip Menu?

Because it sets expectations, drives impulse purchases, and stops you answering the same pricing question ten times a day. A tip menu is not a nice extra, it is part of running your OnlyFans efficiently and profitably. By clearly listing what you offer and how much each item costs, you set clear expectations for subscribers, which helps avoid misunderstandings and disappointment.

Having a menu also encourages more tipping by showing fans exactly how they can support you beyond their subscription. When they see the options laid out, they are far more likely to buy on impulse or try something they would never have thought to request.

On top of that, a tip menu saves you valuable time. Instead of repeatedly answering the same questions about pricing or availability, you can point fans at the menu — which leaves you free to create and engage instead of managing endless messages.

Which Services Belong on Your Tip Menu?

Customs, shoutouts, sexting sessions, a GFE package, exclusive bundles and physical keepsakes. When building your OnlyFans tip menu, you’ll want to include a mix of popular, high-demand services and unique offerings that reflect your personal brand. Here are some common options creators use to maximise tips and keep fans engaged:

• Custom Photos & Videos Tailored content requests give fans a more personal experience and allow you to charge premium rates.
• Personalised Shoutouts Quick, fun, and easy to deliver, shoutouts help fans feel appreciated and noticed.
• Sexting Sessions Real-time messaging interactions are highly sought after and can command higher prices, usually sold as a 4–5 PPV script bundle.
• Girlfriend Experience (GFE) A more intimate and ongoing interaction package that builds deeper fan connections.
• Exclusive Content Bundles Behind-the-scenes clips, themed photo sets, or unreleased content offered as a special package.
• Real-Life Items Physical keepsakes like signed merchandise, Polaroid pictures, or worn clothing can be high-ticket items for devoted fans.

Mixing digital services with tangible items helps you appeal to a wider range of subscriber preferences and price points.

How Do You Price Your Tip Menu?

Value-based, tiered, never below the point where the work stops paying for itself — and with a separate private layer for whales. Setting the right prices for your OnlyFans tip menu can make the difference between average and exceptional earnings. The goal is to strike a balance between affordability for fans and fair compensation for your time, effort, and exclusivity.

1. Research the Market

Before finalizing prices, check what other creators in your niche and content style are charging. This helps you stay competitive while understanding the range fans are willing to pay.

2. Use Value-Based Pricing

Consider the effort, time, and uniqueness of each service. Highly personalised or labour-intensive requests like custom videos or live sessions should be priced higher than quick, repeatable content like shoutouts.

3. Offer Tiered Options

Give subscribers multiple pricing levels to suit different budgets. For example:

• Standard custom photo: $10
• Premium custom set with theme: $25
• Deluxe bundle with video + photos: $50

4. Avoid Undervaluing Your Work

While lower prices may seem like a quick way to attract tips, they can lead to burnout and reduced perceived value. Fans are often willing to pay more for quality and exclusivity. A smart pricing strategy ensures you maximise earnings without sacrificing the quality or sustainability of your work.

5. Whale Pricing Is a Separate Game

Your public tip menu is for the middle of the fan base. The top 1% of fans — who in the accounts we manage generate roughly 15% of monthly revenue — do not buy from the public menu. They buy through private offers with private pricing, tailored to each whale's spending history. Rule of thumb: once a fan hits $500 lifetime spend, every new offer is personalised and priced above the public menu, not below.

How Should You Design and Present the Menu?

Clean, grouped by category, and pinned somewhere nobody has to hunt for it. Your tip menu isn’t just a list, it’s a sales tool. A well-designed, easy-to-read menu makes it more likely that subscribers will explore and purchase your services.

1. Keep It Simple and Visually Appealing

Avoid clutter. Use clean fonts, a consistent color scheme, and just enough design elements to make it stand out without overwhelming readers.

2. Organise by Category

Group services into sections such as Custom Content, Live Interactions, and Exclusive Offers so fans can quickly find what they’re looking for.

3. Make It Easy to Access

Pin your tip menu at the top of your feed, include it in your welcome message to new subscribers, and add it to your bio or highlights. The easier it is to find, the more likely it will be used.

4. Use Helpful Tools and Templates

Platforms like Canva, Photoshop, or even simple text editors can help you create a professional look. Templates can save time while ensuring your design is polished.

5. Let MAHO Management Handle the Work

We build tip menus for the accounts we manage — the layout, the bands, and the mass message that launches it. If you would rather not run your own pricing tests, that is the part we take off your desk.

A clear, attractive tip menu presented in the right way can boost your earnings and help you stand out in a crowded market.

What Does a Tip Menu Look Like at Each Level?

Same structure at every level, different bands: roughly $20–80 per item on a starter menu, $25–200 once you are established, and $300–800 on a premium one. The three examples below use the bands from the table above, so you can lift one straight into your profile.

1. Starter Menu

For creators in their first few months, on the Starter column of the table above.

• Personalised shoutout clip (30 sec) – $20
• Custom photo set (5 images) – $30
• Sexting session, 4–5 PPV script – $40
• Short custom video (1–2 min) – $80

2. Established Menu

For a steady subscriber base, on the Established column.

• Named voice note (60 sec) – $25
• Themed custom photo set – $60
• Sexting session, 4–5 PPV script – $120
• Personalised 3-min custom video – $200

3. Premium Menu

For experienced creators selling scarcity rather than volume, on the Top 1% column.

• All-day texting (GFE) – $300
• Signed photo book, posted to the fan – $400
• 30-min live video call – $500
• 10-min fully customised video – $800

Creative Ideas to Differentiate Your Tip Menu

• Themed Menus: Seasonal or holiday-themed menus (Valentine’s, Halloween, Christmas).
• Mystery Offers: “Mystery Video” or “Surprise Content” at a set price.
• Tiered Bundles: Offer escalating value at higher tiers (e.g., $50, $100, $200 bundles).
• Interactive Options: Polls or fan challenges where subscribers can influence the content.

By customising your tip menu to fit your style, you’ll keep fans engaged while maximising your earning potential.

How Do You Keep Tip Menu Earnings Growing?

Time-limited offers, a refresh every one to two months, a personal thank-you to every tipper, and regular reminders that the menu exists. A well-crafted tip menu is only the beginning: how you use it determines your long-term success. Here are extra strategies to keep your earnings growing:

1. Offer Time-Limited Deals and Seasonal Specials

• Create urgency without cutting the price: bundle instead of discount (e.g. “custom photo set plus a voice note, $30, today only”).
• Align offers with holidays, events, or personal milestones to keep your content fresh and exciting.

2. Update Your Tip Menu Regularly

• Refresh your menu every 1–2 months to reflect new services, content styles, or price adjustments.
• Promote new additions through pinned posts, mass messages, and social media teasers.

3. Engage with Tippers to Boost Loyalty

• Thank every tipper personally — use their name and add one detail only you would know.
• Surprise big spenders with bonus content or exclusive perks to encourage repeat purchases.

4. Promote, Promote, Promote

• Don’t post the menu once and forget it — remind subscribers regularly, especially when you add a new offer.
• Use eye-catching graphics and clear CTAs to make tipping an easy decision.

By combining a thoughtful tip menu with consistent engagement and promotion, you’ll create a system where tips stop being occasional and become a steady, growing part of your income.

How MAHO Management Can Help You Create a Winning Tip Menu

Pricing is the part most creators guess at, and the part where guessing is most expensive. At MAHO Management we build the menu the same way for every account we take on: the bands from the table above, one A/B test per month on the item that sells most, and a private price layer for anyone past $500 lifetime spend.

We also run the launch. A menu nobody sees earns nothing, so it goes into the pinned post, the welcome DM and a mass message, and we watch the first two weeks of conversion before we touch a price again.

Want your menu priced against real numbers instead of a guess? Send us your current menu and we will tell you which three items are underpriced.

FAQ – Common Questions About Tip Menus

Conclusion – Start Earning More with Your Tip Menu

A tip menu does three things at once: it answers the pricing question before it is asked, it gives fans permission to spend beyond the subscription, and it holds your prices steady when a fan pushes. None of that requires a designer. It requires bands you are willing to defend.

Build the starter version this week with four items and one price you find slightly uncomfortable. Watch what sells for two weeks, then adjust the item that did not move — and leave the one that did alone. If you would rather have someone else run that loop, talk to us.