Subscription-based content platforms have transformed the way creators earn money online, offering direct connections with fans and recurring revenue opportunities. While OnlyFans has become the most recognized name in the industry, LoyalFans is quickly gaining traction as a promising alternative. For creators deciding where to focus their time and effort, understanding the differences between these two platforms is essential. In this guide, we’ll compare LoyalFans and OnlyFans across features, payouts, and growth potential—helping you choose the best fit for your content strategy.
At their core, both OnlyFans and LoyalFans allow creators to monetize exclusive content through subscriptions, pay-per-view messaging, and tips. However, the two platforms diverge in several important ways that can directly impact a creator’s earning potential and long-term success.
In short, both platforms serve the same purpose, but the differences in discoverability, monetization tools, and payout structures may make one a better fit depending on a creator’s growth strategy.
When it comes to audience reach, OnlyFans dominates the market with a massive global user base. This gives creators the potential to tap into a much larger pool of paying subscribers. However, the downside is that OnlyFans does not provide strong in-platform discoverability tools—there’s no effective search or recommendation system. As a result, creators must rely heavily on external platforms like Twitter, Reddit, or TikTok to attract new fans.
In contrast, LoyalFans has a smaller user base but makes up for it with better internal discoverability. Its platform includes browsing categories, searchable tags, and creator directories, which help new subscribers find content more easily. For newer or lesser-known creators, this feature can offer a significant advantage in building visibility without being entirely dependent on outside promotion.
When it comes to income streams, OnlyFans keeps it fairly simple. Creators primarily earn through monthly subscriptions, tips, and pay-per-view (PPV) messages. This straightforward system works well for those who prefer a clean, subscription-focused model, but it can feel limiting if you want to diversify your revenue.
LoyalFans, on the other hand, provides a wider range of monetization tools. Beyond subscriptions, tips, and PPV content, creators can also sell content through video stores, host live streaming sessions, and even offer personalized greetings (like shoutouts).This flexibility gives creators more opportunities to tailor their offerings and cater to different fan spending habits, potentially leading to higher overall earnings.
OnlyFans offers a referral program that pays creators5% of the referred creator’s earnings, but the catch is that it only lasts for one year. After that period, you no longer receive referral income, which limits its long-term value.
LoyalFans takes a more creator-friendly approach. They also provide 5% referral earnings, but the big difference is that it applies for life. Not only do you earn from the creators you refer, but you can also get 5% of revenue from fans’ spending if you bring new users to the platform. This makes LoyalFans’ referral system more attractive for those thinking about long-term, passive income.
OnlyFans offers more flexibility when it comes to payouts. Creators can request a withdrawal anytime once they reach the $20minimum threshold, making it ideal for those who want frequent or smaller cash-outs.
LoyalFans, on the other hand, processes payments on a bi-monthly schedule (twice a month). The minimum payout threshold is $50,which may require creators to wait a bit longer to access their earnings compared to OnlyFans.
While OnlyFans gives more freedom in terms of cash flow, LoyalFans’ structure may suit creators who are comfortable with less frequent but larger payouts.
OnlyFans keeps things fairly simple, focusing on a subscription-based model with added features like tipping and direct messaging. While effective, it doesn’t offer many advanced tools for creators to segment their audience or expand engagement beyond the basics.
LoyalFans, however, goes a step further. The platform provides creators with advanced features such as geo-blocking (to restrict content in certain regions), detailed audience analytics, and livestreaming capabilities. These extras give creators more control over their content strategy and a wider range of ways to connect with fans.
In short: OnlyFans is streamlined and straightforward, while LoyalFans caters to creators who want more flexibility and control over their business.
OnlyFans is the most recognized platform in the subscription space, but many creators note that customer service can be slow to respond, particularly for smaller accounts. While the platform is stable and widely trusted, its support structure can leave some creators feeling overlooked.
LoyalFans, on the other hand, takes a more creator-first approach. The platform offers faster and more responsive support, along with regular webinars, tutorials, and educational resources to help creators succeed. This added guidance makes LoyalFans feel more like a community, not just a content platform.
In short: OnlyFans has the name recognition, but LoyalFans invests more in hands-on support and creator education
The right choice depends on your goals and how you plan to grow your audience.
👉 In short: If you rely on brand visibility, OnlyFans may be the better fit. If you value growth tools and long-term earning opportunities, LoyalFans could be the smarter choice.
Choosing between LoyalFans and OnlyFans isn’t always straightforward—and the truth is, success often depends less on the platform itself and more on how you use it. That’s where MAHO Management comes in.
Our team helps creators:
Whether you’re leaning toward OnlyFans, LoyalFans, or considering a multi-platform approach, MAHO ensures you have the tools, guidance, and strategies to grow with confidence.
It depends on your strategy. OnlyFans has a larger audience, which can mean faster growth if you already have strong external promotion. LoyalFans offers more monetization tools and lifetime referral earnings, which may generate more income long term.
Yes. Many creators operate on multiple platforms to diversify income streams and reach different audiences. With the right strategy, you can cross-promote content while tailoring each platform’s unique features to your advantage.
If you already have a following on social media, OnlyFans may help you monetize faster thanks to its brand recognition. If you’re starting from scratch and want better organic discoverability, LoyalFans could be the smarter choice.
Yes. LoyalFans fully supports adult content, just like OnlyFans. Both platforms are creator-friendly and allow NSFW material, provided you follow their terms of service and content guidelines.
Both OnlyFans and LoyalFans offer powerful opportunities for creators, but the right choice depends on your goals. OnlyFans shines with its massive audience and brand recognition, while LoyalFans provides stronger tools for organic discovery, diverse monetization, and long-term earnings through its referral program.
The best platform for you will depend on whether you value reach, recognition, or flexibility in monetization. Take the time to assess your content style, audience-building strategy, and long-term goals before making a decision.
If you’re still unsure, MAHO Management can help. Our team specializes in guiding creators to the platform that best fits their brand and building tailored strategies for growth. Whether you choose OnlyFans, LoyalFans, or both, we’ll help you maximize your visibility and earnings.
👉 Ready to grow smarter? Book a consultation with MAHO Management today and start building the foundation for long-term success.
Copyright © Maho Management
